Skip to content


A Comprehensive Guide to Selecting the Ideal BBQ Smoker

by Erica xie 27 Feb 2024

Your BBQ smoker, a central feature in the realm of outdoor cooking, stands as much more than just a tool; it's a gateway to a world of rich flavors and culinary exploration. Mastering the art of selecting the perfect BBQ smoker goes beyond simply cooking food; it's about enhancing the taste, embracing the process, and showcasing your personal grilling style. This smoker becomes not just an appliance, but a focal point of your outdoor living space, a symbol of your dedication to the craft of barbecue. Here, we'll delve into the essential aspects and expert insights to help you navigate the diverse world of BBQ smokers, transforming your outdoor cooking space into a haven of gastronomic excellence.

BBQ Smoker

Understanding Different Types of BBQ Smokers

The first step in your smoker selection journey is understanding the different types available, each with its unique features and benefits:

Charcoal Smokers: Charcoal smokers, the traditionalists' choice, offer an authentic BBQ experience. The process of managing the charcoal and wood chips to control the temperature and smoke level provides a hands-on approach to grilling. Ideal for those who enjoy the ritual of smoking as much as the flavor it imparts, these smokers are perfect for the BBQ purist. However, they require a learning curve and continuous attention during cooking.

Electric Smokers: These are the modern answer to convenient smoking. With a simple plug-in operation, electric smokers maintain a consistent temperature throughout the cooking process, making them excellent for slow-cooked, tender meats. They're less about the smoke management challenge and more about ease and convenience, suitable for those with limited outdoor space or beginners in the smoking world.

Gas Smokers: Gas smokers offer a good balance between the traditional smoking process and modern convenience. They're typically easy to use, with simple ignition systems and straightforward temperature control. They're great for people who want a relatively hands-off smoking experience but still desire that smoky flavor.

Wood Pellet Smokers: Representing the new age of BBQ smoking, wood pellet smokers are known for their precision and versatility. They use compressed wood pellets and have automated systems to feed the pellets, maintaining a consistent temperature. Ideal for those who appreciate the flavor of wood-smoked meat but want the convenience of an electric smoker.

BBQ Smoker

Budget and Performance Trade-Offs

Understanding your budget and how it aligns with your performance expectations is crucial:

Affordability vs. Quality: While budget constraints are real, it's important to consider the long-term value of your investment. Cheaper models might be tempting but often come with limitations in durability, features, and overall cooking quality. Conversely, more expensive models tend to offer better build quality, longevity, and advanced features like precise temperature control or additional smoking racks.

Feature Prioritization: It's vital to identify which features you cannot compromise on. Do you need a large cooking surface, or are digital controls a must-have for you? Are you looking for a smoker with a built-in thermometer or one that can double as a grill? Prioritizing your needs will help you find the right balance between budget and performance.

BBQ Smoker

Space Considerations: Finding the Right Size

The amount of space you have available for your smoker is a significant factor:

Compact Options for Small Spaces: Limited outdoor space doesn't mean compromising on quality. Many compact or portable smokers are designed to provide excellent smoking capabilities without occupying too much room. Some models are even designed for mobility, perfect for tailgating or camping.

Larger Smokers for Spacious Areas: If you have the luxury of a large backyard or dedicated outdoor cooking area, you might opt for larger smoker models. These typically offer greater cooking capacity, perfect for large gatherings or meal prepping. Additionally, larger models often come with added features like multiple cooking racks, separate chambers for different types of cooking, or advanced technology integration for a more versatile and convenient smoking experience.

BBQ Smoker

Ease of Use and Functionality

The user-friendliness of your smoker can significantly impact your smoking experience:

Simplicity of Operation: For those new to smoking, or who prefer a more straightforward cooking process, the ease of operation is a key consideration. Look for smokers with user-friendly interfaces, clear temperature displays, and convenient features like easy-access ash trays or grease management systems. A smoker that's easy to operate and maintain allows you to focus more on the cooking and less on the equipment.

Temperature Control: Achieving and maintaining the right temperature is critical for successful smoking. Smokers with reliable temperature control mechanisms allow for more consistent cooking results. This is particularly important for recipes that require long smoking times or very specific temperatures.

BBQ Smoker

Maintenance and Durability

Considering the maintenance needs and durability of your smoker will ensure a lasting relationship:

Ease of Cleaning: Regular cleaning and maintenance are essential for the longevity and performance of your smoker. Look for features that facilitate easy cleaning, such as removable components, grease management systems, and materials that are easy to wipe down or rust-resistant.

Construction Quality: A smoker’s build quality directly impacts its durability and performance. High-quality materials like stainless steel or cast iron not only withstand high-temperature cooking but also endure the elements. While higher-quality materials might come with a higher price tag, they can lead to fewer repairs and replacements over time, offering better value in the long run.

BBQ Smoker

Step-by-Step Guide to Choosing Your BBQ Smoker

Step 1: Assess Your Needs Begin by evaluating your grilling habits, space constraints, and budget. Are you a weekend warrior or a daily smoker? Do you have a small balcony or a sprawling backyard? Understanding these factors will help narrow down your options.

Step 2: Research Different Types Spend time researching the different types of smokers. Attend BBQ events, visit stores, or explore online forums and reviews. Understanding the pros and cons of each type based on real experiences can provide valuable insights that go beyond specifications and marketing.

Step 3: Set a Budget Determine a budget range for your smoker. While it's tempting to go for the cheapest option, remember that investing in a quality smoker can enhance your grilling experience and prove to be more cost-effective over time.

BBQ Smoker

Step 4: Consider Space and Size Evaluate the space you have and choose a smoker size accordingly. Larger smokers offer more cooking space but take up more room. Conversely, smaller smokers are more space-efficient but might limit the quantity of food you can smoke at one time.

Step 5: Evaluate Features Examine the features of each smoker within your budget and space constraints. Consider what’s essential for your cooking style and convenience – whether it’s temperature control, ease of cleaning, or versatility.

Step 6: Make Your Decision Based on your thorough research and identified priorities, select the smoker that best suits your needs. Consider it as an investment towards countless enjoyable BBQ sessions.

Step 7: Purchase and Enjoy After making your choice, it's time to purchase your smoker and start enjoying the rich flavors and experiences of BBQ smoking. Experiment with different recipes, invite friends and family over, and relish in the delicious results of your well-chosen smoker.

By striking the perfect balance between functionality and personal preference, you'll master the art of selecting your ideal BBQ smoker. With the insights and guidance provided in this guide, you can transform your outdoor cooking experience into an expression of your culinary style and passion. Experiment, enjoy the process, and let your BBQ smoker become not just a tool for cooking, but a centerpiece of countless memorable gatherings and delicious meals in your outdoor living space.

Prev Post
Next Post

Thanks for subscribing!

This email has been registered!

Shop the look

Choose Options

On your next order when spending over $150

Recently Viewed

Edit Option
Back In Stock Notification
Terms & Conditions
Terms of use of this website
These general terms & conditions are issued by Toughout Limited trading as TOUGHOUT and cover the use (includes but is not limited to visit/access our website, purchase on our site, participation in our promotions and subscribe to our newsletters) of our website –
By accessing and using our website you agree to be bound by these terms and conditions, as well as all applicable laws as governed and interpreted in accordance with the laws of New Zealand. If you do not agree with any of these terms and conditions, do not use the Toughout website.

Limitation of Liability
While we endeavor to provide accurate information on the website, typographical errors, inaccuracies and omissions may occur. Therefore, under no circumstances shall Tougout limited be accepting any liability, direct or indirect, for any kind of loss or damages arising from or in connection with your use of any information contains on this website. You acknowledge that it is solely your responsibility for your action taken in the use of the site.
We reserve the right to make changes or update information at any time without notice.

The website may contain links to external internet websites. Toughout does not guarantee or approve of any material or representations on those websites. Nor do we warrant the connections of this website or any linked site, including any data, program or downloadable files that are free of viruses, Trojan horses, worms or similar devices.

The content of this website is copyright of Toughout Limited or a third party. Toughout does not grant you any intellectual property right in this website. You must not use any trademark displayed on this website. You must only use this website, and you must only display, copy, distribute, or print of this website for personal use. You must not attempt to change, reproduce, add to, remove, hack or interfere with this website or its material.

All payments via our website are processed using SSL protocol to protect your sensitive information, and establishing an account with us using your user ID and password is another great practice for accessing the security area of Toughout website. You can help to protect your details from unauthorized access by keeping your account information confidential and logging out your account each time you finish using the site.
You agree to immediately notify during business hours of any unauthorized use of your account or suspect any attempting money transfer without your permission.
We reserve the right to require proof of identification for security seasons for certain transactions.

Your comments
We welcome you comments regarding the Toughout product, service or website. Any comments, feedback, reviews, photos shall be and remain the property of Toughout Limited. We are entitled to use, disclose, publish and distribute any comments you submitted without compensating you in anyway. We ask you not to send us any comments that you do not want to assign to us or please do not include any confidential information in your comment.

These terms and conditions may change from time to time, we do recommend you review these terms and conditions carefully each time of using the website.

Terms of Trade
When purchase from us, you acknowledge below

All orders are payable in full before delivery. We reserve the right to reject and cancel your order in full or partly where: (a)you are in breach the payment obligations or our inability to obtain authorization for your payment, (b)there has been genuine pricing or product description error, (c)Goods are found out of stock after the order confirmation, or(d) You not meeting the eligibility to order criteria set out in the listing.
Our customer service team will contact you for any cancellations and a refund will be provided on the amount paid that relates to the canceled portion of the order

Pricing and Payment
All prices listed on the Toughout website are in New Zealand Dollars and are GST inclusive. We reserve the right to alter prices on our website at any time for any reason. Online and in store pricing may differ.
Payment options are listed on the checkout page together with your order summary.

Delivery and Shipping
Where the product is able to be delivered/delivery options are listed on each product page.
Delivery and shipping charges will be payable on product purchase and may vary depending on the number of items to be purchased, the size and shape of the products, and your residential addresses.
You will receive an email confirmation once we dispatched your order and if anything causes delays or there is any problem, one of our team will contact you.

Toughout collects your personal information to allow us to supply you with products or services. Please check our privacy policy.
By placing an order through our website, your consent to Toughout collecting your personal information including your name, contact details, and delivery address and agree to provide it to third parties including suppliers and delivery contractors to fulfil and deliver your order.

Further information
A further information can be found on our FAQ page or email us at

this is just a warning
Shopping Cart
0 items